Hey there, foodies! Have you ever had one of those meals that hits the perfect mix of flavor, culture, and simplicity all at once? Well, you’re in for a treat because today we’re talking about a sandwich that does just that—the matjesbrötchen recipe! This isn’t just any sandwich; it’s a German classic packed with history, tradition, and, oh yeah, some mouthwatering goodness.
Picture this: soft, crusty bread rolls stuffed with young, pickled herring (fancy name, Matjes herring), tangy pickles, crunchy onions, and maybe a touch of creamy sauce. Sounds pretty dreamy, right? But what makes it even cooler is that it’s a piece of northern Germany’s culinary culture, often enjoyed as a snack or quick meal during sunny coastal summers.
We’re gonna dig into everything you need to make these sandwiches your new obsession—like the simple ingredients that make it all work, a step-by-step guide so you get it right, and a few fun twists to jazz up the traditional recipe. Oh, and we’ll even spill some tips on what to avoid so you don’t end up with soggy bread (ugh, no thanks). Plus, if you’re the health-conscious type, you’ll love hearing about how herring is not only tasty but also crazy good for you.
Whether you’re all about quick weeknight dinners, exploring different flavors, or just want something unique to share with friends, this matjesbrötchen recipe is your answer. Trust me, once you try it, you’ll feel like you’ve been transported to a German market square. Alright, ready to get this sandwich party started? Let’s go!
Table of Contents
Essential Ingredients for Matjesbrötchen
The beauty of the matjesbrötchen recipe lies in its simplicity. With just a handful of fresh ingredients, you can whip up a sandwich that feels gourmet without all the effort. And the best part? You probably already have some of these at home.
Primary Ingredients for a Classic Matjesbrötchen
First things first—what makes a matjesbrötchen really shine is the quality of its main ingredients.
- Matjes Herring – This is the star of the show! Matjes is young, pickled herring known for being soft and tangy. It’s light but flavorful, perfect for sandwiches. You can find it in jars or cans at grocery stores, usually in the seafood aisle.
- Crusty Bread Rolls – A good sandwich needs good bread, right? Look for a crusty roll—like a Kaiser or rye bread. It’s got to be strong enough to hold the herring, yet soft enough to bite into.
- Onions – Thinly sliced red onions are a must. They add a nice crunch and a little zip that balances the fish. If you find them too sharp, you can soak them in water for a few minutes to mellow the flavor.
- Pickles – Dill pickles bring the perfect tangy crunch. Slice ’em thin and pile them high for maximum yum.

Optional Additions to Enhance Flavor
Want to make your matjesbrötchen recipe pop even more? Here are some extras that’ll take it to the next level.
- Fresh Herbs – A sprinkle of dill, parsley, or even chives adds a fresh, bright flavor that pairs perfectly with the tangy herring.
- Butter or Creamy Sauces – Some people spread a little butter on the bread or whisk up a quick dressing with sour cream, mustard, and dill. It’s a small touch, but wow, does it make a difference.
- Creative Add-ons – Feeling adventurous? Try adding avocado slices for creaminess or a hint of horseradish for heat. It’s your sandwich—make it yours!
With these simple yet flexible ingredients, you’re on your way to crafting a sandwich that’ll have everyone asking for seconds.
Step-by-Step Matjesbrötchen Recipe
Now that you’ve got your ingredients lined up, it’s time to bring it all together. This step-by-step guide will help even kitchen newbies nail the matjesbrötchen recipe without breaking a sweat.

Preparation of Ingredients
Getting everything prepped is half the battle. Here’s what you need to do first!
- Matjes Herring – If the herring is packed in brine, drain it well and pat it dry with a paper towel. Nobody wants a watery sandwich!
- Onions and Pickles – Slice your red onion as thin as you can, and do the same with your pickles. Thin slices mean you get a little crunch without overwhelming the sandwich.
- Bread Rolls – If your rolls are a bit stale or you want an extra crunch, warm them in the oven for a few minutes. Trust me, it makes a difference!
Assembly of a Traditional Matjesbrötchen
Here’s where the magic happens—the assembly!
- Start With the Bread: Cut your bread rolls in half, horizontally. If you’re feeling fancy, spread on a bit of butter or your favorite sauce for an extra layer of flavor.
- Layer the Herring: Lay the matjes herring fillets across the bottom half of the roll. If the fillets are large, you can cut them into sandwich-sized pieces.
- Pile on the Toppings: Add the sliced onions and pickles on top of the herring. This combination of flavors and textures is chef’s kiss.
- Close It Up: Place the top half of the bread roll gently on your masterpiece. Don’t squish it—that perfect bite is all about balance.
Serving and Presentation Techniques
Once your matjesbrötchen is ready, it’s time to serve it up!
- For the Perfect Plate: Add a sprig of fresh dill as a garnish and serve with a side of German potato salad or sauerkraut for an authentic vibe.
- Take It to Go: If you’re packing it for lunch, wrap each sandwich in parchment paper to keep everything neat and tidy.
- Get Creative: Want to wow your guests? Serve it open-faced with the toppings displayed like a work of art.

And there you go—a delicious matjesbrötchen recipe served up just right. Tasty, easy, and oh-so-satisfying!
Popular Variations of Matjesbrötchen
One of the coolest things about the matjesbrötchen recipe is how easy it is to customize. While the classic version is a hit on its own, there’s no harm in adding a little flair. Whether you’re sticking to tradition or exploring new flavors, there’s a version for everyone.
Classic Matjesbrötchen with Dill and Sour Cream
If you’re a stickler for tradition, the original matjesbrötchen has your back. It’s simple but packed with flavor. The sour cream or dill-based sauce ties everything together perfectly. With just herring, onions, pickles, and a touch of dill, this classic combo transports your taste buds straight to a German coast. No fuss, just deliciousness.
Modern Twists on Matjesbrötchen
For those looking to shake things up a bit, modern takes on the matjesbrötchen recipe are where it’s at!
- Spicy Matjesbrötchen – Add a splash of chili sauce or a few slices of hot peppers for a fiery kick.
- Avocado and Beet Matjesbrötchen – Spread some avocado on the bread and sneak in some thin beet slices for a creamy, sweet twist.
- Horseradish Dream – A dab of horseradish cream adds a zesty punch that complements the tangy herring.
The possibilities here are endless! Feel free to go creative with what you’ve got in your fridge.
Scandinavian Influences and Additions
Now, if you’re feeling inspired by our neighbors up north, Scandinavian-style tweaks to the matjesbrötchen recipe will win you over. They’re all about adding items like fresh dill sauces or even pairing the herring with hard-boiled eggs. Some versions even love an open-faced setup, where the toppings shine like a mini piece of edible art. It’s fusion food at its finest!
For more delicious recipe ideas, why not check out our other sandwich recipes on the website? You might just find your next favorite.
Health Benefits of Herring in Matjesbrötchen
Okay, so it’s super tasty, but did you know the matjesbrötchen recipe is also a powerhouse of nutrients? Yep, eating herring isn’t just good—it’s great for you. Here’s how it fuels your body while tantalizing your taste buds.
Rich Source of Omega-3 Fatty Acids
First and foremost—omega-3s! Herring is an oily fish, which means it’s loaded with these healthy fats. Omega-3s are fantastic for keeping your heart happy, reducing inflammation, and even boosting brain function. It’s basically brain food stuffed into a sandwich.
High Protein Content for Energy and Muscle Health
Herring also brings protein to the table—literally! Just one sandwich gives you a generous helping of high-quality protein, which helps repair your muscles and keeps your energy levels steady throughout the day. It’s like a mini fuel-up for your busy life.
Vitamins and Minerals for Overall Well-being
Oh, and there’s more! Matjes is packed with vitamin D for strong bones, vitamin B12 for energy, and selenium, which acts like a secret weapon against cell damage. And the best part? It’s all inside that one yummy sandwich.
If you’re hunting for more dishes that combine nutrition with flavor, check out our recipe ideas page—you’re sure to discover another gem!
There you have it—proof that good food doesn’t just taste nice; it’s good for you too!
Common Mistakes to Avoid When Making Matjesbrötchen
Even the best recipes can go sideways if you’re not careful, and the matjesbrötchen recipe is no exception. Thankfully, these common mistakes are super easy to avoid once you know what to watch out for.
Soggy Bread – The Sandwich Killer
There’s nothing more disappointing than biting into a sandwich and finding it… soggy. Ugh. But good news! You can dodge this disaster by always patting your matjes herring dry before using it. If you’ve got pickles that are juicy (and who doesn’t love pickles?), just shake off the excess liquid or pat them with a paper towel. Oh, and if your bread roll feels soft, try toasting it lightly—instant upgrade!
Overpowering Flavors
Sure, matjes herring is tangy, but it’s not the only star. Overloading the sandwich with strong toppings like heavily spiced pickles or too much sauce can drown out the herring’s unique flavor. Less is more here, my friend. Keep the balance so every ingredient gets its time to shine.
Choosing the Wrong Herring
Not all herring is the same! Mistaking regular pickled herring for matjes can really throw things off. Matjes is young, mild, and delicate—perfect for this recipe. Always double-check labels when shopping, and go for the freshest option your store offers. Trust me, it makes all the difference.
For more sandwich tips and tricks, you might want to check out our other foolproof recipes—you’ll never stress about soggy bread again!
FAQs About Matjesbrötchen
Got questions about the matjesbrötchen recipe? You’re not alone! These are a few of the most common things people wonder about, along with answers to keep your sandwich-making as smooth as butter (or sour cream, in this case).
How Should I Store Leftover Matjesbrötchen?
You probably won’t have leftovers (it’s THAT good), but if you do, here’s what to do. Wrap the sandwich tightly in parchment paper or foil and pop it in the fridge. Just don’t keep it too long—24 hours is the sweet spot. Beyond that, the bread may get too soft, and the flavors could start to blend in unwanted ways.
What Are the Best Serving Suggestions?
This sandwich is versatile! You can serve it as a quick snack, a picnic staple, or even a light dinner. Want to go full German experience? Pair your matjesbrötchen with a cold beer and some potato salad. For a lighter touch, even a simple green salad does the job beautifully.
Is Matjesbrötchen Suitable for All Diets?
Not exactly. While the sandwich itself is packed with healthy ingredients, like herring and fresh veggies, it’s not great for those avoiding seafood or gluten. But don’t worry! There are simple swaps like using gluten-free rolls or exploring veggie-based alternatives if fish isn’t your thing.
If your question wasn’t covered here, check out our recipe page for more helpful tips and tricks to perfect your matjesbrötchen or other fun meals.
And there you have it—no more mysteries, just a tasty sandwich and all the confidence to make it your own!
Pairing Matjesbrötchen with Beverages
Sure, the matjesbrötchen recipe is an absolute winner on its own, but pairing it with the right drink? Oh, that’s when the magic really happens. Whether you’re keeping it traditional or trying something new, the perfect sip can take each bite to the next level.
Traditional Drinks to Try
When it comes to Matjesbrötchen, classic German drink pair like a dream.
- Apple Cider – If you prefer something sweeter, a glass of apple cider can balance the salty tang of the herring perfectly. Plus, it’s a fall favorite, so double points if you’re making Matjesbrötchen in sweater weather.
Modern Pairings Worth a Try
- Flavored Waters – A cucumber or lemon-infused sparkling water keeps things light and refreshing. It’s great for hot summer days when heavier drinks feel like too much.
Non-Alcoholic Options
Don’t drink alcohol? No problem! Here are some no-booze options that still hit the spot.
- Iced Tea – A lightly sweetened iced tea with lemon balances the sandwich’s rich flavors. Green tea-based ones work particularly well.
- Ginger Beer – A non-alcoholic ginger beer is zippy and bright, cutting through the creamy textures of the sandwich.
- Fresh Lemonade – You can’t go wrong with a chilled glass of lemonade. Its zing complements the tangy herring beautifully.
Whatever you choose, don’t forget to hold that drink up and toast to your culinary skills!
Final Thoughts on Matjesbrötchen
You’ve made it to the end of your matjesbrötchen recipe adventure—high five! Hopefully, by now, you’re feeling as in love with this German specialty as we are.
A Quick Recap
To sum it up, the matjesbrötchen recipe is all about simplicity combined with bold, fresh flavors. Soft matjes herring, crunchy onions, tangy pickles, and crusty bread come together for a sandwich that’s just out-of-this-world good. Plus, with endless ingredient and pairing possibilities, you can make it as traditional or modern as you like.
Personal Tips for Matjesbrötchen Success
If this is your first time making Matjesbrötchen, here are a few tips to get it just right next time.
- Always use the freshest matjes herring you can find—it really makes the sandwich shine.
- Toasting the bread roll lightly adds amazing texture (and lets’s face it, warm bread just hits differently).
- Experiment with sauces. A little homemade dill yogurt dressing might change your life!
Oh, and don’t stress if it’s not perfect the first time. Every sandwich is a little different, and that’s all part of the fun.
An Invitation to Try Something New
Now it’s your turn! Head to your kitchen, gather those ingredients, and get creative. Whether you’re making the classic version, adding your own twist, or pairing it with an unusual beverage, there’s no wrong way to enjoy Matjesbrötchen.
If you’re craving more tasty ideas, check out our recipe collection on the website—it’s packed with dishes that’ll inspire your next food adventure. Happy eating!
4 thoughts on “Matjesbrötchen Recipe – A Simple and Delicious German Favorite”